Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alison O'Brien's avatar

This is great advice Carlo, thank you. Thinking of your Dad with steps I take. Wishing him the movement we forget we have. X

Expand full comment
Sam Redlark's avatar

A few years ago there was a TV show called 'Black Sails', that was billed as a prequel to 'Treasure Island'. It ran for four seasons. In addition to the characters created by Robert Louis Stevenson, it included a number of historical pirates, though the writers played fast and loose with what is known about these men and women.

Early on, I assumed that the point of including the likes of Blackbeard and Anne Bonny, in a narrative about fictional pirates, was to lend it an air of authenticity. Later, it became apparent that it was not history that was being dragged into the realm of fiction, but quite the opposite: The point that the show writers were making (or my interpretation of it) is that the history of the golden age of piracy is so riven with hearsay and myth-making, that who is to say that the likes of Long John Silver and Billy Bones weren't also real people? In a show that sometimes strained credibility and erred toward melodrama, it was an unusually subtle piece of meta-commentary.

The boldest example of scene-skipping I have encountered occurs in Cormac McCarthy's novel - 'No Country For Old Men' – which I am about to spoil. If you plan on reading the book, or watching the Coen brother's beautifully-shot adaptation – then you should stop reading.

..........

........

…...

…..

….

...

..

.

The supposed protagonist of the novel, Llewelyn Moss, is murdered off-page at the end of the second act. He is seen alive for the last time, in the company of a young hitch-hiker. The book picks up in the aftermath of his death, as the Sheriff Ed Tom Bell visits the crime scene and attempts to piece together what happened. The transition is even more jarring in the film.

Moss doesn't even die at the hands of the antagonist – an unstoppable force of nature named Anton Chigurh, portrayed on screen by Javier Bardem, who won an Oscar for the performance. Distracted by the girl he is travelling with, he is shot dead by anonymous cartel footsoldiers.

The upshot of this development is the realisation that the actual protagonist of the novel is the afore-mentioned Sheriff Bell – a man who is acutely aware of an escalation of evil in society, but who no longer has any answer for it. It is also the point where the title of the book begins to make sense.

I can't think of a contemporary writer who has explored the nuances of evil better than McCarthy. Chigurh isn't even his best antagonist – that accolade must go to Judge Holden from 'Blood Meridian' – an earthbound fusion of the devil and Prometheus, who builds men and societies up to a point where they bring about their own destruction.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts