Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tracey SCOFFIELD's avatar

As someone who knew you then and now, I read this doing my shopping and burst into tears in the middle of King Street.

Expand full comment
Sam Redlark's avatar

Happy Birthday Hanif.

Having worked in a hospital and having witnessed both the seriously injured and the terminally ill find their way back to their old dispositions, I suspected that, once humour began to surface in your diary entries, whatever the condition of your body, your mind would would reframe your existence and would once more express itself creatively. Each one of us has to find our own reasons to live. Some people manage to survive and that is all. Despite the strong unfavourable odds, you have done more than simply endure. You are alive and it shows in everything you write.

In a short story, titled 'The Other', the writer Jorge Luis Borges, then in his dotage, has a chance meeting with his younger self. For the older Borges, it is February, 1969. He is in the city of Cambridge, near Boston, sitting on a bench beside the Charles River. The younger Borges is under the impression that he is in Geneva, also seated on a bench, beside the Rhône. For him, it is sometime around 1914.

The pair debate whether their meeting is a dream and, if that is the case, then which of them is the dreamer. The younger of the two is naturally more opinionated and idealistic. He is incredulous that his counterpart possesses only a hazy memory of the works of Dostoyevsky and is incandescent at the suggestion that the poet Walt Whitman might be capable of expressing a falsehood. The older Borges, who is more philosophical, attempts to update his junior on five decades of family news, mostly deaths and marriages. He is wrong in his claim that the poetry he has written will bring more joy to himself than it will to others. I loves his verse and return to 'Manuscript Found in a Book of Joseph Conrad' more than I do to any other poem.

It is touching how the older Borges assumes a fatherly role when attempting to dampen down his younger self's naïve expression of socialism, and to reassure him in regard to the gradual decline of his memory and his eyesight; the latter is so bad that he can barely see and is waiting for a carer to return to the bench and escort him home. Privately, he concludes that, for the younger Borges, their encounter has been a dream, but that for him it has been a real occurrence.

I have gone in search of my younger self, in Kensington Gardens, near to what is often referred to as Round Pond, though it is actually shaped more like an ornate tea tray. If he is anywhere to be found, then it will be there. He will be 19 or thereabouts. It will be Autumn. The air will be damp and uncomfortably chilly. Parts of the park will be badly waterlogged. He will be alone on a bench somewhere off the beaten track. It will be lunchtime. Referring to the contents of a Tower Records bag, acquired on Kensington High Street, I will inform him that R.E.M. are from Athens Georgia, in the US and not, as he believes (influenced by the spectacle of Bill Berry's bushy Mediterranean eyebrows) Athens, Greece.

“I still own that compact disc,” I will tell him. “It still plays. Only old men buy them now.”

I should tell him that his life turns out as he thinks that it will, but that would be cruel and I doubt that it would change very much. As Borges concluded “There was no point in giving advice, no point in arguing, because the young man's inevitable fate was to be the man that I am now”.

Expand full comment
39 more comments...

No posts