Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Leyla Sanai's avatar

This is one of the most traumatic things I’ve read for ages. My heart aches for these young lost girls. So often, if they receive the unconditional love and support they deserve from their families, they would not sink to such degradation. The hypocrisy of the man is indeed shocking, but we know about that from the grooming gangs. We don’t hear much about the lost Muslim girls though.

My sister didn’t go down this path but because she wasn’t as academic as my dad hoped, she dropped sciences before O level, much to his shock. There was then a terrible dysfunctional atmosphere in which my mother, who was 17 years younger than my father and hated him, almost encouraged my sister in her rebellion, even when it was clearly harming my sister. Staying out all night aged 14 and 15, bringing men back to her room, dropping not only sciences but English and then art, both of which she excelled at.

She ended up addicted to heroin and one day jumped or fell in front of a tube, age 22. I was 21.

There is a terrible grief for all of the family . We were not Muslim, we were secular atheists. But, in the same way as Muslim communities are closed, many immigrants refuse to reach out for help. And many are absolute: ‘ if my daughter does not become a barrister or a doctor, I’m not going to support her.’ That wasn’t the way it was with my dad, who was a kind man, but I’m wondering if that was the way it was with the girls in this tragic story.

Can’t we agitate for the opening of a charity for lost girls in their teens and 20s? Provide guidance, show them that rebellion does not have to include self-destruction. Find their strengths, encourage them to build on them. Tell them about further education and the means to access it. Mediate between families.

The first step has to be better integration . My family was pretty well integrated, and reading this story it sounds as if the family of at least one of the girls was high achieving. But you can be high achieving and accepted and yet still not integrate. There needs to be a way of gently teaching adult immigrants about the values of this country and tolerance. We need to also let them know that it it’s okay if your child doesn’t immediately clamber up the career ladder you wish for them. There are other ways of living and being happy. But not this.

Do you know what happened to the two girls in the story, Hanif? I have a terrible heaviness in my heart. I’m writing this from hospital where I’ve had my second leg amputated, so I’m a wheelchairiie like you. Physical trauma is possible to tolerate if you have love. But if you are a child and you don’t have love and acceptance from someone in your life, be at your parents or your peers; if you like guidance, you can get very very lost. The world can be a dark and cruel place.

Expand full comment
Jane Rankin-Reid's avatar

This is the kind of story telling that first got your writing noticed decades ago, and with good reason. Thank you for re-sharing!

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts